April 2, 2007

Terrible Job, arXiv


ArXiv.org, the major physics and math preprint site just changed their paper archiving format from a perfectly respectable one that had no major flaws or drawbacks to an extremely cryptic and awful one that nobody asked for. If it isn't broke, change it to an impossible and uninformative format? It used to be that they subdivided the different areas of physics into categories like astrophysics (astro-ph) and condensed matter (cond-mat) and then numbered them YYMM and then 3 numbers for the order in which it was added. So the first paper posted this month in high energy theory would be read hep-th/0704001, then hep-th/0704002, and so on. "Wow," you are saying, "that is really sensible and easy to understand. Anyone using a system like that for the past 16 years that everyone is used to and has no problems with would never change it unless they just wanted to make trouble and piss people off." Obviously, this is what just happened. Now, even though the different categories are still there to look at, they aren't part of the numbering scheme, which now goes YYMM.[4 random-looking numbers]. Awesome job guys, now instead of seeing astro-ph/0608303 and knowing that it is about astrophysics, and is from somewhere in the middle of August, 2006, I can look at arXiv:0706.8974 and have no clue what the hell is going on. People are going to start dropping the subject headings, I just know it. And the web address doesn't have the subject in it anymore either. AND part of the supposed advantage of their retarded new scheme is that they can now add further sub-categories with an additional dot. As in astro-ph.JK/0705.0505. Why the hell would you go from a non-decimal system to a system with TWO?! This multiple period garbage is an assault on my senses! Why couldn't they just come up with a system using @#$%^&* and the greek alphabet? If you need to subdivide, do what they've already done in certain fields. To separate cosmology and stellar physics within astro-ph, just make them astro-co and astro-st. Sticking periods all over the place is a recipe for disaster. Of course, today's [arXiv:astro-ph/0704.0221] is titled "The Return of a Static Universe and the End of Cosmology," so with cosmology ending, I won't have to put up with this horrible system much longer.

1 comments:

Zosia A. C. Krusberg said...

my paper just made it! http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0703224